Ajax Pickering News Advertiser - November 29, 2007
PICKERING -- It doesn't bother Valerie McNaughton that her floors are
slanted or that her doors are crooked. In fact, she thinks it adds
character to her home. What bothers her is the fact that she can't open
her windows and that her furnace doesn't work properly.
"The floors are wonky, but I love my house," she said. "I just want them
to fix it."
And she definitely doesn't want to move. Ms. McNaughton moved into the
Henry Major House in Whitevale, which was built in 1820, in 2000. The
property was expropriated by the provincial government in the early 1970s
and tenants have rented the home ever since.
But, from the moment Ms. McNaughton moved in, she's experienced continuous
problems, ones she thinks aren't too difficult to fix. In fact, she's even
offered to do some of the repairs herself, as long as the property manager
provides her with the materials. But she said her offers have been brushed
aside each time.
"It's always 'tomorrow, tomorrow, or next month, next month'," she said.
Although she hasn't been served with an eviction notice, she said the
landlord, the Ontario Realty Corporation (ORC), has deemed it too
expensive to fix, and has begun offering Ms. McNaughton alternatives.
She explained the alternatives include: moving to a house on Altona Road
(which she says is tiny, and has no basement), another on Whitevale Road
(which her kids have renamed "The Amityville
House"), or compensating her
with $10,000.
ORC spokesman Bill Moore said initial offers for Ms. McNaughton to move
were due to "her discomfort in the house." The home has been deemed
habitable and he said there is no intention to evict her at this time. As
for repairs, he said there is still some work to be done, but each repair
is significant.
"As for the property itself, long-term plans for the property are being
reviewed," he said.
Ward 3 Regional Councillor Rick Johnson said moving the McNaughton family
somewhere else will only intensify the home's deterioration.
"If you leave it empty for the winter all the pipes are going to freeze up
and it'll be worse every year you leave it for winter without heat in the
house," he said. "It will be a situation of having to tear it down and
demolish it because it won't be good for anything after that."
He added the Henry Major House is one of the oldest homes in Pickering,
and he would like it to be there for Pickering's 200th anniversary in
2011.
At a recent Council meeting, he put forward a motion requesting the ORC to
immediately commit to repair and maintain occupancy of the home, with
hopes to protect and preserve it "as one of the most important heritage
sites in the Whitevale Heritage Conservation District."
Coun. Johnson believes the biggest problem in the situation is neglect. He
said the expropriation by the federal and provincial governments has "torn
the heart out of central Pickering and north Pickering."
Although there is a list of at least 20 things that need to be fixed,
there is only a handful of items Ms. McNaughton feels must be done. First,
she would like her furnace fixed.
"I can put a Kleenex on the vent and it won't blow off," she said. She
added her hydro bill has been roughly $1,500 for three months, and she
thinks this is due to the furnace's inefficiency.
"Financially, I'm not going to be able to afford it," she said.
When she moved in, the roof was new, but the ceiling was leaking and it
hasn't stopped, so she'd like that repaired. She'd also like to be able to
open her windows, which have been bolted shut since she moved in.
She said she's willing to compromise, and won't mind if the repairs are
done every couple of months.
Coun. Johnson believes a reason the repairs are not being done is to save
costs. He said bureaucrats are given a certain budget to work with each
year and if some of the buildings are torn down, they'll have the same
budget to look after fewer homes the next. But, he added the problems
don't all rest with Del; it started with the government 35 years ago.
"It's sad, you know, when you've got a tenant that wants to stay there and
doesn't want to leave and you've got a landlord who really doesn't care,"
he said. "That makes it sad."
As for Ms. McNaughton, she said "I just want to live my life."